High school softball: Freshman provides huge hit as Elyria rallies for win, finishes as tourney’s only undefeated team

Bob Daniels | The Chronicle-Telegram

LAGRANGE — It was one of those situations the bat-and-ball sports do better than any other: Two outs, bottom of the last inning, runners at first and second, home team down a run, 6-5.
Little freshman center fielder steps into the batter’s box and drills the first pitch down the right-field line for a two-run triple, and the good guys — in this case, Elyria High’s softball team — defeat Columbus St. Francis DeSales, 7-6.
The Pioneers (18-2) went home undefeated in four games, the only unbeaten among a dozen teams in an annual invitational that concluded Saturday afternoon. And, lest we overlook a reality of the Prebis Memorial Classic, the freshman’s triple left Elyria the only Lorain County team not to lose in the final round of the annual round-robin.
Host Keystone, Midview and Wellington all dropped one-run decisions to out-of-county teams in the fourth and final round.
And Elyria Catholic, which posted a big win over Twinsburg in the first of its two games, was mercy-ruled by Nordonia in the finale.
Elyria’s freshman hero is Alanna Williams, a diminutive outfielder-utility player whose ringing bottom-of-the-seventh triple sent another freshman, Alyssa Barker, and senior All-American pitcher-shortstop Tess Sito home with the winning runs.
“The pitch was outside, but I just hit it so I could help my team,” Williams said. “I thought she (DeSales’ right fielder) was going to catch it. But she didn’t and I just ran as hard as I could. “
“When I saw the ball drop, I was just thinking I have to score so we can win this game and I know Tess behind me is fast and she’s gonna score,” Barker said. “I was excited that we won, because we’re undefeated in this tournament.”
It’s not like heroism is a new experience for Williams. It was her single that drove Sito home for the Pioneers’ second run in a 2-0 victory over Tallmadge in the first game of the afternoon. Until she came through with the chips down in the third inning, Elyria led just 1-0 after Ashlee Stolarski drove Kristen Boros home in the first.
Coach Ken Fenik, whose third-ranked Pioneers seemed to be on the verge of defeat, was relieved after Williams uncorked her triple. Sito, the starting and winning pitcher in Elyria’s first three games, did not start against DeSales. But she finished in relief and picked up the win.
“What a game,” Fenik said. “I didn’t want to throw Tess, because she needed a rest. But after we scored those runs (cutting DeSales’ lead to 6-5), Tess more or less had fire in her eyes. She wanted it. When she went out there (to pitch), you could see the swagger in the rest of the team. I’m very proud of them, because we were down.”
Keystone, which thrashed Canfield 7-2 in its first game Saturday, nearly caught Tallmadge after trailing 5-3 in the nightcap. The Wildcats (16-2) got a one-out single from sophomore Casidy Gregory in the bottom of the seventh, and she scored when Kenzie Conrad reached on an error with two out. But although they loaded the bases with two out, the Wildcats couldn’t push across the equalizer.
Wellington dropped a 4-3 heartbreaker to Canfield in its second Saturday game after defeating DeSales, 3-2, in the first. The big blow in the opener was Megan Auble’s solo home run, her first of the season.
“She tried to throw me a riseball, but I stayed down on it,” Auble said.
Midview went 1-3 for the tournament and all four of its games were decided by one run. The Middies lost to Twinsburg, 1-0, in Saturday’s second game after dropping a tough 5-4 decision to Nordonia earlier in the day. A big hit in the Nordonia game was Sydney Mencke’s fence-clearing homer.
“It’s been a while since I hit a good one like that,” Mencke said. “I’ve been in kind of a slump the last couple games. I don’t know what she threw me, but if I guessed I’d say it was just outside, just about right there (indicating waist high). I knew it was going to go when I hit it. You can just feel it in the bat.”
Even though they were routed in the second game, Elyria Catholic’s Panthers were sharp in a 6-4 victory over Twinsburg in the first. In that one, Emily Thompson hit a single and double, Emily Taylor had two singles and two RBIs and Jasmin Filiaggi hit a two-run double.
“This is probably the best game we’ve played,” said Panthers assistant coach Dan Spencer, filling in for head coach Brian Daw, who could not attend. “This is the team we really are. This is one of the best games I’ve ever seen them play.”

PREBIS CLASSIC

Third round

Keystone 7, Canfield 2
Elyria 2, Tallmadge 0
Nordonia 5, Midview 4
Wellington 3, Columbus DeSales 2
Elyria Catholic 6, Twinsburg 4

Fourth round

Tallmadge 5, Keystone 4
Elyria 7, Columbus DeSales 6
Twinsburg 1, Midview 0
Canfield 4, Wellington 3
Nordonia 11, Elyria Catholic 1 (5 innings)

FINAL STANDINGS

Elyria 4-0, Keystone 2-1, Twinsburg 2-1, Wellington 2-2,
Canfield 2-2, Nordonia 2-2, Elyria Catholic 1-1, Tallmadge 1-1,
Uniontown Lake 1-1, Massillon Jackson 1-1, Midview 1-3,
Columbus DeSales 0-4